Most tears of the meniscus do not heal on their own. A small tear in the outer rim (the red zone) has a good chance of healing. However, tears in the inner part of the meniscus often require surgery. When tears in this area are causing symptoms, they tend to get bigger. This puts the articular cartilage on the surfaces of the knee joint at risk of injury.

Surgeons aim to save the meniscus. If an injured part must be removed, only the smallest amount of the meniscus is taken out. Preserving the nearby areas of the meniscus is vital for keeping the knee healthy. If a tear can possibly be repaired, surgeons will recommend a meniscal repair.

A torn meniscus may cause symptoms of pain and swelling and sometimes catching and locking. The goal of surgery is to take these symptoms away. When the knee locks and you have to tug on it to get it moving, a small flap from a meniscal tear may have developed. The flap may be getting caught in the knee joint as you bend it. Or a small piece of the meniscus could actually be floating around inside the joint. This fragment, called a loose body, can get lodged between the moving parts of the knee, causing the knee to lock. In these cases, surgery may be needed, sometimes right away, to fix the flap or to remove the loose body.

Only when the majority of the meniscus is damaged beyond repair is the entire meniscus removed. Surgeons are experimenting with solutions to replace the meniscus.

Meniscus Surgery Candidates

Although meniscal transplants have been performed for more than 20 years, the procedure is still relatively uncommon. This is largely due to the strict criteria patients must meet to be considered for the procedure.

Most people with severe meniscal problems have also developed arthritis in the knee. If the articular cartilage has worn away too much, a meniscal transplant will not be helpful.

The criteria for meniscal transplant include:

• Younger than 55 years and physically active
• Missing more than half of a meniscus as a result of previous surgery or injury, or a meniscus tear that cannot be repaired
• Persistent activity-related pain
• Knee with stable ligaments and normal alignment
• No or minimal knee arthritis
• Not obese

Meniscus Surgery Outcome & Benifits

The research studies that have been done on meniscal transplants are not perfect. Overall, between 21% and 55% of transplants fail within 10 years. Meniscal transplants on the outside (lateral) part of the knee are more successful than those on the inside (medial) of the knee.

Synthetic (artificial) meniscal tissue has been tried, but there is conflicting information at this time.

Meniscal transplants can be quite helpful, but are not a good option for every patient. For patients who are carefully and correctly selected, meniscal transplant surgery can provide significant benefits.

Prepare for Meniscus Surgery

You and your surgeon should make the decision to proceed with surgery together. You need to understand as much about the procedure as possible. If you have concerns or questions, be sure and talk to your surgeon.

Once you decide on surgery, you need to take several steps. Your surgeon may suggest a complete physical examination by your regular doctor. This exam helps ensure that you are in the best possible condition to undergo the operation.

You may also need to spend time with the physical therapist who will be managing your rehabilitation after surgery. This allows you to get a head start on your recovery. One purpose of this preoperative visit is to record a baseline of information. The therapist will check your current pain levels, ability to do your activities, and the movement and strength of each knee.

A second purpose of the preoperative visit is to prepare you for surgery. The therapist will teach you how to walk safely using crutches or a walker. And you'll begin learning some of the exercises you'll use during your recovery.

On the day of your surgery, you will probably be admitted for surgery early in the morning. You shouldn't eat or drink anything after midnight the night before.

Meniscus Surgery Overview

Meniscal surgery is done using an arthroscope, a small fiber-optic TV camera that is used to see and operate inside the joint. Only small incisions are needed during arthroscopy. The surgeon does not need to open the knee joint.

Before surgery you will be placed under either general anesthesia or a type of spinal anesthesia. The surgeon begins the operation by making two or three small openings into the knee, called portals. These portals are where the arthroscope and surgical instruments are placed inside the knee. Care is taken to protect the nearby nerves and blood vessels.

Partial Meniscectomy

The procedure to carefully remove a damaged portion of the meniscus is called partial meniscectomy. The surgeon starts by inserting the arthroscope into one of the portals. A probe is placed into another portal. The surgeon watches on a screen while probing the meniscus. All parts of the inside of the knee joint are examined. When a meniscal tear is found, the surgeon determines the type and location of the tear. Surgical instruments are placed into another portal and are used to remove the torn portion of meniscus.

When the problem part of the meniscus has been removed, the surgeon checks the knee again with the probe to be sure no other tears are present. A small motorized cutter is used to trim and shape the cut edge of the meniscus. The joint is flushed with sterile saline to wash away debris from the injury or from the surgery. The portals are closed with sutures.

Meniscal Repair

Suture Repair

Using the arthroscope and a probe, the surgeon locates the tear. The probe is used to push the torn edges of the meniscus together. A small rasp or shaver is used to roughen the edges of the tear. Then a hollow tube called a cannula is inserted through one of the portals. The surgeon threads a suture through the cannula and into the knee joint. The suture is sewn into the two edges of the tear. The surgeon tugs on the thread to bring the torn edges close together. The suture is secured by tying two to three knots. Additional sutures are placed side by side until the entire tear is fixed.

An alternate method is to pierce the knee joint with one or two curved needles. The needle goes from the outer edge of the meniscus completely through the tear. The surgeon may feed a suture from another portal into the end of the needle. Or the suture can be threaded into the needle from the outside of the knee. Both ways get the suture through the tear and allow the surgeon to sew the torn edges of the meniscus together.

Suture Anchor Repair

Special fasteners, called suture anchors, are sometimes used to anchor the torn edges of the meniscus together. These implants are biodegradable, meaning they eventually break down and are absorbed by the body. Suture anchors have barbed shafts and are pointed like an arrow. They work like a staple or straight pin to hold the healing tissues together.

Repairs using suture anchors work best for younger patients who have a single tear near the outer rim (red zone) of the meniscus. (As described earlier, this part of the meniscus has the richest blood supply.) A probe is often used to line up the torn edges of the meniscus. Then the surgeon uses a small surgical tool to punch an arrow through the damaged part of the meniscus. Usually only two or three arrows are needed. Larger tears may require up to six arrows. The arrows anchor the two torn edges together while the tear heals. It takes about six months before the arrows begin to be absorbed by the body.

Meniscal Transplantation

If the meniscus cannot be repaired or has been previously removed, a new form of treatment may offer a way to slow the onset of knee arthritis. Meniscal transplantation uses borrowed tissue to take the place of the original meniscus. Experiments have been tried using various replacement materials. One material that is showing promise is an allograft. An allograft is tissue that is from a donor, usually preserved human meniscus tissue. Because it is so new, this surgery is currently only available for select patients in a limited number of locations.

Using the arthroscope, the surgeon removes remnants of the old meniscus. Next, the allograft is prepared. Small sutures are placed around the edges of the allograft. The surgeon slides the allograft with the sutures into the knee through a small incision. The allograft is sewn in place onto the tibia bone. Surgical instruments, including a cannula or needle (described earlier), may be used to secure additional sutures. Some surgeons also use special anchors to firmly fix the allograft in place. A probe is used to make sure the transplanted meniscus holds securely. The arthroscope is removed, and the portals are sewn shut.

Meniscus Surgery Recovery

Meniscal surgery is done on an outpatient basis. Patients usually go home the same day as the surgery. The portals are covered with surgical strips, and the knee may be wrapped in an elastic bandage.

Crutches are used after meniscal surgery. They may only be needed for one to two days after a simple meniscectomy. Surgeons specify how much weight can be borne after meniscal repair or allograft transplant. Patients having meniscal repair are usually told not to place any weight on the foot for four to six weeks after surgery. After a transplant procedure, most patients are instructed to touch only the toes of the operated leg on the ground for four to six weeks. Some sugeons allow their patients to place a comfortable amount of weight on the foot four weeks after repair or transplant surgery.

Patients who have had a meniscal repair or transplant usually wear a knee brace for at least four weeks. The brace keeps the knee straight. It is removed often during the day to do easy range-of-motion exercises for the knee.

Follow your surgeon's instructions about how much weight to place on your foot while standing or walking. Avoid doing too much, too quickly. You may be told to use a cold pack on the knee and to keep your leg elevated and supported.

Meniscus Surgery After Care

Your rehabilitation will depend on the type of surgery you had. You probably won't need formal physical therapy after partial meniscectomy. Most patients can do their exercises as part of a home program. If you require outpatient physical therapy, you will probably need to attend therapy sessions for two to four weeks. You should expect full recovery to take up to three months.

Many surgeons have their patients take part in formal physical therapy after meniscal repair and transplant procedures. The first few physical therapy treatments are designed to help control the pain and swelling from the surgery. Physical therapists will also work with patients to make sure they are putting only a safe amount of weight on the affected leg.

For the first six weeks after a meniscal repair, you should avoid bending the knee more than 90 degrees. Then it is safe to gradually bend the knee fully. However, you should avoid squatting for at least three to four months while the repair fully heals. It is not advisable to run, jump, or twist the knee for at least four to six months. Patients sometimes resume sport activities within four to six months after surgery to repair the meniscus.

Range-of-motion exercises start right away after a transplant. The goal is to get the knee to bend to 90 degrees within four weeks after surgery. As time goes on, more challenging exercises are chosen to safely advance the knee's range of motion, strength, and function.

Ideally, patients will be able to resume their previous activities. Some patients may be encouraged to modify their activity choices, especially if an allograft was used.

The physical therapist's goal is to help you keep your pain under control and improve your knee's range of motion and strength. When you are well under way, regular visits to your therapist's office will end. The therapist will continue to be a resource, but you will be in charge of doing your exercises as part of an ongoing home program.

Meniscus Surgery Possible Risks

The risk of complications from meniscal transplant surgery is very slight. Stiffness, reoperation, and incomplete healing are the most common complications.

Other risks include bleeding, infection, and nerve or blood vessel injury.

The risk of getting an infection from donor tissue is small, but it has happened. You are twice as likely to be struck by lightning (1 in 800,000 chance) than to contract HIV from a meniscal transplant (1 in 1.6 million chance).